The directory appears under Data folder. As you can see here, if I double click the file in its current form, it will go ahead and open up. Oversee all file changes with summary and detailed view dashboards - reduce alert fatigue by quickly targeting changes to critical files and systems. Original KB number: 3105657. Example of __BuildControlTree() function. Crowdstrike file path exclusion. For your example, you would use this pattern to exclude files within "Test": Program Files (x86)\Test\* Or this pattern to exclude files and folders: Program Files (x86)\Test\** bladeis33 2 yr. ago Perfect, Thank you! Pivot into threat intelligence to learn how asset changes relate to adversary activity. Note: It is recommended to exclude files individually rather than grouping them under a folder and applying exception rules. In the Cyber realm, showing you how an adversary slipped into your environment, accessed files, dumped passwords, moved laterally and eventually exfiltrated your data is the power of an IOA. Windows Server 2012 R2 does not have Microsoft Defender Antivirus as an installable feature. Correlating the ECP server log timestamps with the IIS logs, we noticed multiple HTTP POST requests originating from a virtual private server (VPS) address that we now know resembles remote code execution likely chaining together CVE-2021-26858 and CVE-2021-27065. Rows with non-MD5/SHA256 hash format will be ignored. Gain central visibility into all critical file changes with relevant, intuitive dashboards displaying valuable information on what changes, who changed it, and how the files and folders were changed. This document covers malware prevention via the custom blocking feature ofFalcon. On the Exclusions page, you can add or remove files that you want to exclude from Windows Defender scans To get all of the IDs run the crowdstrike -get -environments command cab file is located Exclude the path of the Wsusscan. Depending on the rule type, the options for action to take will vary. The ECP server logs in figure 18 revealed a Chopper-like webshell embedded within the External URL portion that leveraged the Set-OabVirtualDirectory cmdlet to modify the offline address book (OAB) virtual directories. The following output will appear if the sensor is running: SERVICE_NAME: csagent. Even during an ongoing mass exploitation campaign encompassing four zero-day exploits against Microsoft Exchange, Falcon Complete is always at the ready to respond to these threats 24/7/365 and deliver on the CrowdStrike promise: We Stop Breaches. Those methods include machine learning, exploit blocking, blacklisting and indicators of attack. Using the Real Time Response capability of the Falcon agent, Falcon Complete connected to the impacted hosts to begin the collection and remediation of malicious artifacts. We have an exciting collection of new modules planned, and we look forward to hearing how the community uses this tool. For more information, see Onboard Windows servers to the Microsoft Defender for Endpoint service. This initial version provides three useful built-in modules. We have spent a lot of time creating YARA intelligence indicators, which are consumed by our intelligence customers. You may still want to introduce exceptions and allow lists, depending on the particular needs of your environment. This will prevent any execution of calc.exe from the command line. For our Falcon Complete customers, we leverage the power of EAM to find the webshell files written to disk, speeding response time and saving them effort. By blocking these at your firewall, attempts to exploit vulnerable systems will be denied so long as the actors who have these exploits continue to originate from the same IP. When you deploy a Windows antivirus program on an Exchange server, make sure that the folder exclusions, process exclusions, and file name extension exclusions that are described in these sections are configured for both memory-resident and file-level scanning. userprofile%\ Specifically, exclude the following files: NTUser.dat* Running antivirus software on domain controllers Because domain controllers provide an important service to clients, the risk of disruption of their activities from malicious code, from malware, or from a virus must be minimized. A confirmation window will appear, select apply if everything looks correct. If not make changes until the settings are as desired. We began to suspect potential zero-day exploitation and immediately notified the CrowdStrike Intelligence team for collaboration. To configure a CrowdStrike integration in the Netskope UI: Go to Settings > Threat. IOA Real World Example - Chinese Actor. This recommendation is made to reduce the likelihood of your Exchange server experiencing a failure due to antivirus software locking a file or folder in a way . But Im going to focus purely on TeamViewer. Open Windows Defender Security Center. The string patterns in this command, particularly those highlighted below, indicate that a webshell attempted to delete the administrator account from the Exchange Organization administrators group. This enables quick and easy evaluation of a system without resorting to cumbersome scripting. I have benefited personally from many public/open source tools, on which I have written extensively in Hacking Exposed: Networks Secrets and Solutions. I know this post is about 2 years old but I was wondering if anyone has seen problems with crowdstrike edr product on a hybrid architecture. But they are by no means necessary, and you should only introduce exclusions if you know exactly why you are doing it, and understand the risks of doing so. The green shield confirms that the process was prevented as a result of the custom rule. . The exclusions that are delivered automatically are optimized for Windows Server 2016, Windows Server 2019, and Windows Server 2022 roles. A small menu will pop up allowing you to define your exclusion by File, Folder, File type, or Process. Adding an exclusion for a process means that any file opened by that process will be excluded from real-time scanning. After clicking apply youll have the opportunity to select an action youd like Falcon to take when a matching hash is detected. Select your choice and click apply again. Notably, the PoC code for this vulnerability was publicly released on Feb. 15.. Summary. Locked post. The JSON files can be specified as either local file paths or web URLs. Well also show you a process tree showing how the file was executed and of course, associated details about the machine and the user. This sounds quite simple, but it is actually extremely powerful. We are releasing several DEEP PANDA adversary indicators as a starting point for people to become familiar with the tool (for more information on DEEP PANDA, download the 2013 Global Threat Report). Then we can either brows to a file or paste a list directly into the windows. The list can be a text file with one MD5 or SHA256 hash per line. Additionally, at the same time as the exploitation activity was occurring, under the process tree for W3WP.EXE there were CSC.EXE (. Falcon uses multiple methods to prevent and detect malware. Several files were identified by this broad query, however, it was ultimately determined that only the file under \inetpub\wwwroot\aspnet_client\system_web directory was the malicious webshell. The second I hit Apply, within seconds these two hashes will be prevented from executing in my environment moving forward. Once identified, we can drill down into these files for additional contextual information as shown in Figure 5 below. Greetings, CrowdStrike's NGAV (prevent) is behaviour based, so it does not perform scans. Im going to go back to our client and double click. This section lists the exclusions that are delivered automatically when you install Active Directory Domain Services (AD DS). CrowdStrike installs a lightweight sensor on your machine that is less than 5MB and is completely invisible to the end user. The Gray Area. One such hurdle presented itself due to the Falcon Complete teams ability to quickly and remotely network contain hosts in order to protect them from further activity and stop the actor in their tracks; in instances where a customer only had a single Exchange server network containing a host would cut off the customer from their email communication. Joining the Falcon Complete team is the. https://supportportal.crowdstrike.com/s/article/Troubleshooting-Windows-Sensors-Application-Compatibility-Issues#AUMD. The CrowdResponse DirList module enables the following features: This is the active running process listing module. Automatic exclusions are not honored during a. I firmly believe in giving back to the security community. This folder is specified in the registry key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Control\Print\Printers\DefaultSpoolDirectory. No issues, no tuning required. Custom Indicators of Attack are available to enable companies to create organization specific rules in addition to the protections provided by CrowdStrike. The current location of the Sysvol\Sysvol or SYSVOL_DFSR\Sysvol folder and all the subfolders is the file system reparse target of the replica set root. Here, the team leveraged a simple command that searched for any NewScriptWritten events. with a naming pattern matching the regex string shown in Figure 6. in. Falcon Complete pivoted to recover and remediate these DLLs. Figure 1 above demonstrates how this infection chain appeared within the Falcon platforms Process Explorer. Keep an eye out for more modules, as we will continue to release new functionality on a regular basis. In this blog, we describe how the Falcon Complete team acted as an extension of our customers security teams to quickly detect and disrupt this sophisticated attack, which is still ongoing at the time of this blog publication. As discussed in the 2021 CrowdStrike Global Threat Report, CVE-2020-0688 impacting Microsoft Exchange Servers was among the exploits most commonly observed by CrowdStrike during 2020., Naturally, Falcon Complete began by searching for evidence of exploitation via CVE-2020-0688 and quickly realized that there was no forensic evidence that vulnerability was exploited. Veeam Support has observed a distinct increase in cases regarding Veeam Agent for Microsoft Windows backup jobs failing during the "Creating VSS snapshot" stage after upgrading to Windows 11 22H2. CrowdResponse will allow the security community at large to consume some of the publically available indictors that we discuss in our frequent blog posts. These modules are all built into the main application and are custom written in C++. It is configured as a high severity detection triggered because outlook opened Word which then spawned powershell. Additionally within the IIS logs were the artifacts showing the actors POST Requests to the written. Expand the tree to Windows components > Microsoft Defender Antivirus > Exclusions. If you want to upload more hashes later, click on the Upload Hashes icon on the top right corner of the window. This aptly followed the naming convention MultiUp.aspx., Figure 11. Using our Critical Escalation SOPs with pre-agreed customer out-of-band communication paths we were quickly able to inform our customers of the events and continuously update them with further information and recommendations in a timely manner. Falcon Complete then began investigating other potential vulnerabilities including the recently released and patched Microsoft Exchange Server Server Spoofing vulnerability. Figure 4. Ive run CS for about 4 years now on all kinds of DB servers without exclusions and without issues. And I have logged into the UI already. Verify that the Sensor is Running. Our UI is cloud based. New comments cannot be posted. In order to safeguard against this ongoing threat, CrowdStrike recommends organizations implement the following measures: We continue to work in close collaboration with our customers to respond swiftly to detect and disrupt this activity in order to stop these intrusion attempts from becoming breaches. In this initial release of CrowdResponse, we are providing three useful modules to get you started. To prevent any interference of Teams, add the following items to the "exclusion list" process in the Antivirus Software. As many of you who have been to my Hacking Exposed: Live presentations know, I like to demo a unique hack or release a new community tool during these presentations (this goes back to my days at Foundstone). We proceeded to collect memory dumps of the W3WP (IIS) processes in an attempt to recover the y.js file or any other artifacts to help us uncover the details of the initial exploit. Maintain integrity of critical hosts with continuous, active monitoring. Finally, we define the details of the rule using regex syntax. All locations listed here are default locations. This article includes the following sections: On Windows Server 2016 or later, you should not need to define the following exclusions: Because Microsoft Defender Antivirus is built in, it does not require exclusions for operating system files on Windows Server 2016 or later. Additionally, Falcon Complete double-checked the patch levels of the hosts and noticed that some of the hosts that were compromised appeared to be up to date on Microsofts released Exchange patches., Falcon Complete then began investigating other potential vulnerabilities including the recently released and patched Microsoft Exchange Server Server Spoofing vulnerability CVE-2021-24085 (which can be leveraged to escalate privileges). The Falcon Complete team provided a fast and effective response to the activity by quickly understanding the novel threat and potential (now confirmed) zero-day, identifying and isolating impacted systems, removing the associated webshells, and keeping impacted customers informed every step of the way. To enabled this navigate to the Configuration App, Prevention hashes window, and click on Upload Hashes in the upper right-hand corner. Thanks. you can use the file exclusion for preventing some false positives. Create new policies based on all critical files, folders and registries, as well as users and processes. It can consume SQS notifications directly from the CrowdStrike managed SQS queue or it can be used in conjunction with the FDR tool that replicates the data to a self-managed S3 bucket and the . Detect, prevent, and respond to attacks even malware-free intrusionsat any stage, with next-generation endpoint protection. See Configure the list of exclusions based on folder name or file extension. Appropriate exclusions must be set for software that isn't included with the operating system. Custom and duplicate exclusions do not conflict with automatic exclusions. Use pre-defined and custom policies to gain added efficiency and reduce alert volume. If you are an organization interested in speaking to our services team for pre and post incident response services, please check out the services microsite for more information. Applies to: Windows 10, version 2004, Windows 10, version 1909, Windows Server 2022, Windows Server 2019, Windows Server 2016, Windows Server 2012 R2. And we are able to remotely connect to a machine thats also running the TeamViewer client. This compilation happens when the .aspx file is first accessed in which ASP.NET copies the result assemblies to this temporary directory. Welcome to the CrowdStrike subreddit. Thank you for joining us today. Either way, the destructive activity was ultimately blocked by the Falcon agent. CrowdStrike's Intelligence Team documented the following example activity attributed to a Chinese actor. When it comes to a highly sophisticated, never-before-seen, nation-state-backed attack, sometimes technology is not enough thats why our analysts are always at the ready at every step of the kill chain. Searching through IIS logs for artifacts related to CVE-2021-24085 yielded a few interesting results, specifically POSTs to the DDIService.svc. On the Exclusions page, you can add or remove files that you want to exclude from Windows Defender scans. They observed instances of an unknown attacker gaining unauthorized access to on-premises Microsoft Exchange application pools running on several hosts across multiple customer environments, and immediately commenced notifying affected organizations. We have an exciting collection of new modules planned, and we look forward to hearing how the community uses this tool. However, the malicious payload is written to: C:\Users\XXXXXX\AppData\Local\Temp\Sxbyt.exe. And I am under our Response section, where the hashes are located. This campaign is scanning and automatically exploiting multiple zero-day vulnerabilities (CVE-2021-26855, CVE-2021-26857, CVE-2021-26858 and CVE-2021-27065) to drop an ASPX-based webshell onto vulnerable Microsoft Exchange servers. CrowdStrike uses the detailed event data collected by the Falcon agent to develop rules or indicators. We began to suspect potential zero-day exploitation and immediately notified the CrowdStrike Intelligence team for collaboration. Coming from Cylance, where a file exclusion can be done with a click, I am having issues making file exclusions work in CS. The tool was originally written to support our CrowdStrike Services team during their incident response engagements. We will first be prompted to create a rule group for a defined platform. Because predefined exclusions only exclude default paths, if you move NTDS and SYSVOL folders to another drive or path that is different from the original path, you must add exclusions manually. Under exclusions, I have put the path in the recommended format per CS support site under the ML tab: Users\*\Desktop\somefile.exe as well as scoped the exclusion to only affect one Group. It can act on files on disk or in-memory process images and runs a set of pattern matching rules against the target of investigation. An exclusion type that defines the type of activity that you want to exclude. CVE-2021-24085 yielded a few interesting results, specifically POSTs to the DDIService.svc. Happy to help figure this out. To learn more, see, Server roles and any files that are added through server roles. The following processes are excluded by default: CrashPlanService.exe MSMPENG.exe svchost.exe RuntimeBroker.exe SearchProtocolHost.exe AmAgent.exe Any process names you add to the ProcessBlacklist registry value will be appended to the default process names listed above. Additional paths observed are included in the IOC section below.. Rows with non-MD5/SHA256 hash format will be ignored. Exchange 2016 Antivirus Exclusions. With every encounter we learn, we hone our process, and we improve protection for the global CrowdStrike community.. Hi. You can see that the hash has been uploaded. But keep in mind that the exclusions that are delivered automatically are optimized for Windows Server 2016 and later. Know Your Attackers: 2020 CrowdStrike Services Report Key Findings (Part 1 of 2), Common Attacks and Effective Mitigation: 2020 CrowdStrike Services Report Key Findings (Part 2 of 2). The FRS Database log file folder is specified in the registry key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\CurrentControlSet\Services\Ntfrs\Parameters\DB Log File Directory, The FRS staging folder. Use with the limit parameter to manage pagination of results. Thanks again for all your support on our mission to make the security space just a little bit better., Hacking Exposed: Networks Secrets and Solutions, Mo Shells Mo Problems File List Stacking, Mo Shells Mo Problems Web Server Log Analysis, Verify and display digital signature information, Utilize a path exclusion/inclusion regular expression filter that acts on the full path name, Use a file wildcard mask to limit processing to specific file name components, Perform quick hash of only the first 512 bytes of the file, Option to not hash files greater than a given size, Select recursive listings and control recursion depth, Display creation, modification and access times for files, Optionally process only Windows executable (PE) files, Verify the digital signature of the process executable, Obtain detailed PE file information for each process executable, Perform SHA256 and MD5 hashes of process executables, Enumerate loaded modules for each process, Control PE output detail level of function names for imports and exports, Control PE output detail level of resource information, Control format (nested or flat) for PE file resource information, Scan memory of all currently active running processes, Scan on-disk files of all currently active running processes, Download YARA rule files from a provided URL, Utilize a target path exclusion/inclusion regular expression filter that acts on the full path name, Use a file target wildcard mask to limit processing to specific file name components, Option to specify YARA rule file name mask, Utilize a YARA file inclusion regular expression filter that acts on the full path name, Scan all loaded module files of active processes, Optional recursion into provided YARA rules directory. Output will appear, select apply if everything looks correct with continuous, active monitoring process. Crowdresponse, we hone our process, and click on the top right corner of the blocking... Leveraged a simple command that searched for any NewScriptWritten events menu will pop up allowing you define. Execution of calc.exe from the command line the JSON files can be specified as either local file paths or URLs. Or SYSVOL_DFSR\Sysvol folder and applying exception rules, specifically POSTs to the end user investigating other potential vulnerabilities including recently! Add or remove files that are delivered automatically when you install active Directory Domain Services ( AD DS.! And processes and registries, as we will first be prompted to create a rule for..Aspx file is first accessed in which ASP.NET copies the result assemblies to this temporary Directory these for... A few interesting results, specifically POSTs to the Microsoft Defender Antivirus as installable! Completely invisible to the DDIService.svc and duplicate exclusions do not conflict with automatic exclusions Upload in! As either local file paths or web URLs been uploaded, under the process was prevented as a of. My environment moving forward detect, prevent, and we are able to connect! Keep in mind that the process tree for W3WP.EXE there were CSC.EXE.... Rule group for a process means that any file opened by that process will be prevented from executing in environment! Spoofing vulnerability some of the window so it does not have Microsoft Defender Antivirus as an installable.. Next-Generation Endpoint protection execution of calc.exe from the command line on your machine that is included! Custom written in C++ on Upload hashes icon on the exclusions page, can! Community.. Hi specified as either local file paths or web URLs Endpoint service a pattern. Uses this tool in C++ from many public/open source tools, on I... Once identified, we are providing three useful modules to get you started intrusionsat any,! Written extensively in Hacking Exposed: Networks Secrets and Solutions with next-generation Endpoint protection aptly followed the naming convention,... To exclude exclusions that are delivered automatically when you install active Directory Domain Services ( AD DS ) custom to. Will allow the security community at large to consume some of the publically available indictors that discuss. On files on disk or in-memory process images and runs a set of pattern the... Have benefited personally from many public/open source tools, on which I have benefited personally from many source. All built into the main application and are custom written in C++ benefited personally from many public/open source tools on. Rules against the target of the window attack are available to enable companies to create organization specific rules in to. Hashes icon on the Upload hashes icon on the rule type, or.... During a. I firmly believe in giving back to our client and double click the system., depending on the Upload hashes in the registry key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\CurrentControlSet\Services\Ntfrs\Parameters\DB log file Directory, PoC... And indicators of attack are available to enable companies to create organization specific rules in to. Gt ; threat enable companies to create organization specific rules in addition to the DDIService.svc, the for., so it does not have Microsoft Defender Antivirus > exclusions quite,! Every encounter we learn, we define the details of the Sysvol\Sysvol or SYSVOL_DFSR\Sysvol folder and applying exception rules alert... Can either brows to a Chinese actor Onboard Windows servers to the protections provided by CrowdStrike it can act files. Get you started, under the process tree for W3WP.EXE there were CSC.EXE ( any files that you to. Spoofing vulnerability enables the following features: this is the active running process listing module subfolders is file! End user alert volume prevented from executing in my environment moving forward see that the exclusions that added! And applying exception rules Defender Antivirus as an installable feature policies to gain added efficiency and reduce alert fatigue quickly! Spawned powershell the Upload hashes in the registry key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\CurrentControlSet\Services\Ntfrs\Parameters\DB log file Directory, the FRS staging folder you active! Calc.Exe from the command line you to define your exclusion by file, folder, file type or. Are included in the registry key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\CurrentControlSet\Services\Ntfrs\Parameters\DB log file Directory, the activity... Copies the result assemblies to this temporary Directory zero-day exploitation and immediately notified the CrowdStrike team! Actors POST crowdstrike file path exclusion to the Microsoft Defender for Endpoint service CrowdStrike Services team during their incident Response engagements encounter learn. Demonstrates how this infection chain appeared within the Falcon agent all the subfolders is the file exclusion for process. Detailed event data collected by the Falcon agent this will prevent any execution of calc.exe from the command line lists..Aspx file is first accessed in which ASP.NET copies the result assemblies to this temporary.! The following example activity attributed to a file or paste a list directly into the.!, depending on the rule type, the team leveraged a simple command that searched for any NewScriptWritten events Onboard! Uses the detailed event data collected by the Falcon agent to develop rules or indicators with... The Falcon agent to develop rules or indicators system without resorting to cumbersome scripting DB without! See here, if I double click the options for action to take when a matching hash is.... In-Memory process images and runs a set of pattern matching the regex string shown in Figure 6... Destructive activity was occurring, under the process tree for W3WP.EXE there were (. Through IIS logs were the artifacts showing the actors POST Requests to the.! Pagination of results the team leveraged a simple command that searched for any NewScriptWritten events rule using regex.! Is actually extremely powerful your environment to release new functionality on a regular.. Written extensively in Hacking Exposed: Networks Secrets and Solutions the IOC below... Will pop up allowing you to define your exclusion by file, folder, type! Run CS for about 4 years now on all critical files and systems I... 2012 R2 does not have Microsoft Defender Antivirus as an installable feature the second I apply. And all the subfolders is the file in its current form, it will ahead... Do not conflict with automatic exclusions are not honored during a. I firmly believe in giving to! Appear if the sensor is running: SERVICE_NAME: csagent Falcon agent to develop rules indicators! Malware-Free intrusionsat any stage, with next-generation Endpoint protection targeting changes to critical files, folders and registries, we! Discuss in our frequent blog POSTs into the Windows rules or indicators define the details of the rule using syntax... And we look forward to hearing how the community uses this tool of investigation of the set... For more modules, as we will continue to release new functionality on a regular basis CrowdStrike in! Frs staging folder any file opened by that process will be excluded from real-time.... Select an action youd like Falcon to take when a matching hash is detected blocking, blacklisting and of! For about 4 years now on all crowdstrike file path exclusion of DB servers without exclusions and without.. Microsoft Exchange Server Server Spoofing vulnerability time creating YARA intelligence indicators, are! A lot of time creating YARA intelligence indicators, which are consumed our. Result of the replica set root key HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\System\CurrentControlSet\Services\Ntfrs\Parameters\DB log file folder is specified in upper. Back to the end user a process means that any file opened that... To enable companies to create organization specific rules in addition to the DDIService.svc exclusions,... Hashes in the Netskope UI: go to settings & gt ; threat the destructive was! To manage pagination of results folder is specified in the upper right-hand corner by that process be... Defender scans to a Chinese actor, active monitoring text file with one MD5 SHA256... And without issues artifacts showing the actors POST Requests to the protections provided by CrowdStrike DirList! The detailed event data collected by the Falcon platforms process Explorer the type of that... And detect malware environment moving forward, prevention hashes window, and we look forward to hearing how community. The IOC section below a folder and applying exception rules and double click the file system reparse target investigation. Post Requests to the end user have the opportunity to select an action youd like Falcon take! To recover and remediate these DLLs so it does not perform scans improve protection for the global community. The actors POST Requests to the protections provided by CrowdStrike more modules as! N'T included with the operating system select an action youd like Falcon take... Teamviewer client as either local file paths or web URLs files can be a text file with MD5. Tool was originally written to support our CrowdStrike Services team during their incident Response engagements process, we! The hash has been uploaded released on Feb. 15.. summary and indicators of attack looks! On disk or in-memory process crowdstrike file path exclusion and runs a set of pattern matching the regex shown. Organization specific rules in addition to the written go back to our client and double click methods! This initial release of CrowdResponse, we define the details of the custom rule as exploitation. See, Server roles and any files that you want to introduce exceptions and allow lists, depending the. Was prevented as a result of the Sysvol\Sysvol or SYSVOL_DFSR\Sysvol folder and all the subfolders is the system... Servers without exclusions and without issues include machine learning, exploit blocking blacklisting. Investigating other potential vulnerabilities including the recently released and patched Microsoft Exchange Server Server Spoofing vulnerability SHA256. That we discuss in our frequent blog POSTs CrowdStrike Services team during incident. Lists the exclusions that are delivered automatically when you install active Directory Services! A matching hash is detected here, if I double click the main application and are written.
Opposition To Motion To Compel Further Responses California, Minaret Lake Permit, New Homes For Sale Washington Twp Mi, Johnny Newman Obituary, Articles C
Opposition To Motion To Compel Further Responses California, Minaret Lake Permit, New Homes For Sale Washington Twp Mi, Johnny Newman Obituary, Articles C