Averaging about two kilogramsbut occasionally growing as large as a human headthe chestnut-like tubers are ingested in their raw form or after roasting (Crase et al.). In this respect the exhibition offers a response to Eric Michaelss claim, originally made in the context of debates over commercial, cultural and aesthetic values, that Indigenous art is the product of too many discourses.13 Indigenous art in Everywhen appears less as a discursive surplus (assuming that such excess could be strictly determined) than as a position from which to interrogate other discourses, while also asserting its own internal concerns. Before turning to art in her late 70s, she also worked as a cameleera role usually reserved for men, which enabled her to impart physical strength and boldness to her strokes (Neale, Emily Kame Kngwarreye). It certainly made a mockery of the idea of time as a forward-flying arrow. By including works such as these, the exhibition reveals that the contemporary does not require a definition founded solely in conceptual art. In 1988, Kngwarreyes batiks appeared as part of the international exhibition Utopia A Picture Story. 2 The aesthetic dimension of Indigenous art. 9 Erin Manning, Relationscapes: Movement, Art, Philosophy, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 2009, pp 158-159. In their fusing of rudimentary means with secret, inherited knowledge, theres something magical about these pieces. The exhibition has been guest curated for the Harvard Art Museums by Indigenous Australian Stephen Gilchrist, of the Yamatji people of the Inggarda language group of Western Australia. It thus demonstrates the capacity for an object to move through alternative registers of meaning and value, hence entering alternative discursive fields. Download Kngwarray from Bridgeman Images archive a library of millions of art, illustrations, Photos and videos. As its title suggests, the exhibition argues that Indigenous art distinguishes itself by focusing on a layered relationship to past, present and future experience. We acknowledge the Wurundjeri Woi-Wurrung People as the Traditional Owners of the land on which the NGV is built. From a Postconceptual to an Aporetic Conception of the Contemporary, View of the Performance-themed gallery in the exhibition, 52 Artists: A Feminist Milestone at the Aldrich Contemporary Art Museum, Into View: Bernice Bing at the Asian Art Museum, San Francisco, Through the Algorithm: Empire, Power and World-Making in Basel Abbas and Ruanne Abou-Rahmes If only this mountain between us could be ground to dust at the Art Institute Chicago, Intimate Estrangements: Bharti Kher: The Body is a Place at the Arnolfini, BOOK REVIEW: Jacob Lund, The Changing Constitution of the Present: Essays on the Work of Art in Times of Contemporaneity, Lumbung will Continue (Somewhere Else): Documenta Fifteen and the Fault Lines of Context and Translation, On and Off NDAFFA #: An Extended Review of the 14th Dakar Biennale, Behind the Algorithm: Migration, Mexican Women and Digital Bias Mnica Alczar-Duartes Second Nature, BOOK REVIEW: Banu Karaca, The National Frame: Art and State Violence in Turkey and Germany, Notes on the Palestine Poster Project Archive: Ecological Imaginaries, Iconographies, Nationalisms and Knowledge in Palestine and Israel, 1947now, Diversity and Decoloniality: The Canadian Art Establishments New Clothes, Cathy Lus Interior Garden at the Chinese Culture Center of San Francisco, In the Black Fantastic: Afro-futurism Arrives at the Hayward Gallery, On Caring Institutions, Safe Spaces and Collaborations beyond Exhibitions: An Interview with Robert Gabris, Media Aesthetics of Collaborative Witnessing: Three Takes on Three Doors Forensic Architecture / Forensis, Initiative 19. New York, Columbia University Press, 2016. Her paintings powerfully counter the homogenising temporal order imposed on Aboriginal people and their plant-kin networks by Australian settler society since the late-eighteenth century (Donaldson). To facilitate the emergence of antjulkinah, Anmatyerre people perform special songs and dances as part of increase ceremonies (Soos and Latz). Read more Location Clemenger BBDO Auditorium, NGV International 180 St Kilda Road Melbourne Victoria 3000 More details Watch, Listen, Read Sydney, Craftsman House, 1998. Best known as a judge and co-host of MasterChef Australia, Preston is also a senior editor for delicious and taste magazine. The Dreaming can refer to these narratives, to the sacred sites the ancestors created through their actions, and to the laws they handed down. Anwerlarr angerr "Big yam" (1996) by Emily Kam Kngwarray, Aboriginal Australian (Anmatyerre). Performance indicates the role of ceremonies and rituals practiced by Indigenous peoples as a means not only of renewing their bonds to the landscape, but also of forging and reinforcing social bonds. Kngwarray, Emily Kam (1910-96) Marks of Meaning: The Genius of Emily Kame Kngwarreye. Aboriginal Temporality and the British Invasion of Australia. Artlink, vol. Read more, Michael Williams is the Director of the Wheeler Centre for Books, Writing and Ideas in Melbourne. Clinton held his first solo exhibition in 1996 at Hogarth Galleries, Sydney. Catalog; For You; WhereTraveler Boston. Anmatyerre Woman. An Anmatyerre elder and lifelong custodian of women's 'dreaming' sites in her clan country of Alhalkere, Emily Kame Kngwarreye (1910-1996) developed an abstract visual language centred around ancestral spirits and Australian Aboriginal cosmology. Sydney, Allen & Unwin, 2010. On these grounds, Indigenous art is contemporary for it occupies, physically and discursively, multiple temporal registers. While, as the author shows, Elkin made some sound observations in relation to Aboriginal culture, his assimilationist views reflect an ideology underlying forced removal of Indigenous children and contribute to the ongoing experience of intergenerational trauma for First Nations. SB15, 7 February - 11 June 2023. Osbornes attempt to found a concept of the contemporary on a rigorous philosophical basis offers a rich and complex theory of art and temporality. Australasian Plant Conservation, vol. Instead, her pictorial style evolved towards less naturalistic visualisations employing intricate brushstrokes to elicit the subterranean circuitries of the pencil yam. Wanting to know more about Aboriginal understandings of wild yams, I came across the mesmerising paintings of Elder Emily Kame Kngwarreye. His painting, in natural ochres, is much more austere. In her role at the NGV she has curatorial From the standpoint of human-vegetal entanglement, Kngwarreyes yam paintings disclose the biocultural role of her art within an Anmatyerre spiritual ecology. When asked about her paintings, Kngwarreye responded in terms of the all-embracing totality of Awelye Dreaming and Anmatyerre country: Whole lot, thats whole lot. The disjuncture of Osbornes thesis refers to the manifold relations, practices and narratives in art after internalising the failure of conceptual art to locate the specificity of art solely within its aesthetic character. A visual phytopoetics of hetero-temporality factors into other paintings of this period, including Arlatyeye Wild Yam (1991) (Kngwarreye, Arlatyeye Wild Yam), with its dot-seed field superimposed over a mesh of linear traces, and Yam Dreaming (1991) (Kngwarreye, Yam Dreaming) with its pattern of larger dabs arranged within a latticework that evokes the microscopic vein and stomatal structure of leaves. The very act of painting the piece can be thought of as a performance, or the reiteration of a sacred action. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Results will return exact matches only.Any images with overlay of text may not produce accurate results.Details of larger images will search for their corresponding detail. 268 notes z. x. isabella-ibis reblogged this from hawkesart. Kngwarreyes yam-art constitutes such an interface, an opening that intervenes in the negation of vegetal diffranceof yam poiesis. Kngwarreyes wild yam Dreaming is entrained to the hetero-temporality of the plant within its biocultural network. Your guide to staying entertained, from live shows and outdoor fun to the newest in museums, movies, TV, books, dining, and more. That paradox can be expressed in terms akin to Osbornes original formulation that contemporary art is postconceptual art. First, Osbornes thesis focuses almost exclusively on the history of Western art and artists, noting that it is chiefly conceptual art and its lessons from Europe and North America that provide the foundational conditions for contemporary art. De la Grammatologie. What Is Eco-Phenomenology? Eco-Phenomenology: Back to the Earth Itself, edited by Charles Brown and Ted Toadvine. The suggestion, as the museums former director Tom Lentz explains in the catalogs foreword, is that for Indigenous Australians, past, present, and future overlap and influence one another in ways that defy Western notions of time as a forward-flying arrow.. See Laura Fisher, The Art/Ethnography Binary: Post-Colonial Tensions within the Field of Australian Aboriginal Art, Cultural Sociology, 6, no 2, 2012, pp 251-270. The series Anooralya (1995), for instance, epitomises her evolution towards tendrilous traces painted against white, gray or black fields. Furthermore, composed in engrossing yellow hues but lacking the underlying structures characteristic of the previous paintings, Kame (1991) calls forth the pencil yam seeds vital to Kngwarreyes Dreaming (Kngwarreye, Kame). Ellen van Neerven is the award-winning author of Heat and Light, Comfort Food and Throat. Big Yam. To exist out of season, for Marder, is to exist out of tune with the milestones of vegetal time: germination, growth, blossoming, and fruition (in Irigaray and Marder 143). Photo: Harvard Art Museums, President and Fellows of Harvard College. In a similar gesture towards the postconceptual, Rover Thomass Yari country (1989) successfully binds together aesthetic and non-aesthetic aspects of artistic production. The yam is but one node within a network of beingsof land and Dreaming, of the natural and otherworldly. The network of bold white lines on black, derived from womens striped body paintings, suggests the roots of the pencil yam spreading beneath the ground and the cracks in the ground created as it ripens. It's a powerful and huge (8 metres x 3 metres) painting covered with a tangle of curving white brushstrokes, forming an organic pattern that represents the roots of the yam and the cracks of the earth in desert country, and also the spiritual sense of country of this indigenous artist. Thats what I paint, The perspective I am adopting hereone predicated on the interwoven agencies of flora and artsituates Kngwarreyes work within a Dreaming ecology of Central Desert people that recognises plants as percipient kin. In the late 1830s, for instance, British writer-explorer George Grey characterised wild yam, or warren, as a favourite article of food among Noongar people (12). Change), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Emily Kame Kngwarreyes Big yam Dreaming is one of my favourite paintings by an Australian artist. On display is posthumous selection of her artworks. Courtesy National Gallery of Victoria, Melbourne Undoubtedly, artistic developments of the 20th century, including modernism, have been crucial in how global audiences have approached Kngwarreye's work. The elaborate and dense configuration of dots invokes the dispersal of yam seeds across the landscape in conjunction with the footprints of emus in search of them. Printed on luxury 170gsm Hanno Silk Art paper Sydney, Craftsman House, 1998. As part of his project, Osborne offers six qualities that he states mark the contemporary as emerging from the legacy of conceptual art. Emily Kame Kngwarreye was born in 1910 in a remote desert area known as Utopia, 230 kilometres north-east of Alice Springs. This painting is accompanied with DACOU Aboriginal Art Gallery documentation. This is plant hetero-temporality: the manifestation of times passage in the body of the plant. Through Vegetal Being: Two Philosophical Perspectives. The exhibition could thus be said to figure forth the contemporary not only as internally disjunctive, but also (and paradoxically) as aporetic at its very core. These include painted baskets, wooden bowls, engraved pearl shells, and a woven skirt. Canberra, Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies, 1986. Alyawarra Music: Songs and Society in a Central Australian Community. Yam Dreaming. 6 Disjunctive unity of meaning. Drag your file here or click Browse below. Aboriginal clap sticks are played in conjunction with the didgeridoo for ceremonial dances. These premises ground contemporary art, and its period, within the legacy of conceptual art, leading to his summary position that contemporary art is postconceptual art. Aboriginal painting on canvas reached, in my opinion, an apogee of beauty in works by such artists as Turkey Tolson, Mick Namarari, Dorothy Napangardi, Kitty Kantilla, and more recently, Warlimpirrnga Tjapaltjarri, whose recent show in New York drew, Dorothy Napangardis Karntakurlangu Jukurrpa.. But how much can iconic art teach us about the world today? Composed in various hues of purple, the batik evokes/invokes a field profuse in plump yams with textured skin enclosed in a meshwork of twisting rhizomes and twining stems (Neale, Origins 65). Available throughout most of the year, the storage organscomparable to potatoesare either eaten raw or cooked in hot ashes or sand. (This is a critical consequence of arts necessary conceptuality.). Moving outside the constraints of two-dimensional aesthetic imagery, her art invokes the poiesis of the yamits making, bringing-forth and becoming in the world, its opening to the other in synchrony with the artists opening in response to it. F E AT U R E S At the beginning of the twenty-first century, Indigenous art stands as one of the most prominent and vital forms of contemporary art, because it focuses attention upon the conflict over temporality and the definition of contemporaneity itself.2 One of the key challenges remains the problem of outlining conditions of possibility for contemporary art that can account for the intersection of Indigenous and non-Indigenous perspectives. New York, Columbia University Press, 2013. Disease, slaughter, dispossession, and lack of recourse (thanks in part to the British designation of the continent, which had been occupied for 50,000 years, as terra nullius nobodys land) almost destroyed Aboriginal culture. (All art requires some form of materialization; that is to say, aesthetic felt, spatio-temporal presentation. The only work in Everywhen that reaches these heights is Napangardis Karntakurlangu Jukurrpa, 2002. Yari Country, painted in 1989, is a rectangle divided by dotted lines into four quadrants. Big yam Dreaming (Anwerlarr anganenty), 1995, synthetic polymer paint on canvas. The Australian Aborigines: How To Understand Them. Utopia: The Genius of Emily Kame Kngwarreye, edited by Margo Neale. Green, Jenny. Whereas some Alyawarra invocations communicate traditional biocultural knowledge concerning the harvesting of yams, others celebratein gustatory fashionthe nourishment afforded by the rhizomatous plants as a staple crop in the Central Desert landscape: Yams growing in small gullies and fissures climb up the trunks of nearby trees during the wet season; Pieces of bark are used to dig up the young tubers; walupalu pakiytjurtu waralara pakiytjurtu. Through her concerted attention to the wild yam, Kngwarreye came to embody the plants Altyerre, the creation or Dreaming being connected to the species. See W E H Stanner, The Dreaming & Other Essays, Black Inc. McLean, Ian. Read more, Matt Preston is an award-winning food journalist, restaurant critic and television personality. Anooralya Wild Yam (1989) is one of several works during this transformational phase in the artists phytopoetics that narrates the ancestral entanglement between the yam and the emu (Kngwarreye, Anooralya IV). Her memories of working the land show that yams and other plant species figured into her identity as their beingness interlaced with hers. Kngwarreye, Emily Kame. Those realities include far-flung communities that are riven by alcohol and child abuse, a preponderance of really bad art made either in dismal or overly controlled conditions, and a dissonance between political rhetoric and reality that pains the brain to think upon. Hallam, Sylvia. I first became aware of Aboriginal Australians cultivation of wild yams through archaeologist Sylvia Hallams classic Fire and Hearth, published in 1975. He has worked at the Wheeler Centre since inception in 2009, when he was hired as the Head of Programming before being appointed as Director in September 2011. Why do we need Aby Warburg today? Along these lines, Kngwarreyes work makes perceptible the elusive pulsations of yam-time that otherwise might remain concealed (Marder 103). After a lifetime of painting on sand and bodies, Kngwarreye turned towards batik in the late 1970s as a medium for expressing traditional Anmatyerre Dreaming narratives (Museums Victoria). Holt, Janet. Wood, David. In brief, phytography examines plant-non-plant biographies through a conception of poiesis as shared making, collective bringing-forth and multispecies becoming. The need to preserve agency is made particularly evident by Jennifer Biddle, who argues that Indigenous art functions as a means of resistance to the ongoing political oppression of Indigenous peoples in Australia. In this context, ecocritic Alfred Siewers employs the neologism time-plexity to denote the entwining of chronos and kairosof human and more-than-human modes of time. Reducible to neither an artefact nor an object, her paintings are agential things-in-themselves, like the plants they engage. CAMBRIDGE, MASS.- The Harvard Art Museums present Everywhen: The Eternal Present in Indigenous Art from Australia, on display in the museums' Special Exhibitions Gallery from February 5 through September 18, 2016. , like the plants they engage for it occupies, physically and,... Of Alice Springs consequence of arts necessary conceptuality. ) solely in conceptual.... Four quadrants Kngwarreye, edited by Margo Neale arts necessary conceptuality..! Desert area known as a judge and co-host of MasterChef Australia, is... Of Emily Kame Kngwarreyes Big yam Dreaming is one of my favourite paintings by an Australian artist felt, presentation... Kngwarreye was born in 1910 in a remote desert area known as Utopia, 230 kilometres north-east of Springs. Kngwarreyes batiks appeared as part of increase ceremonies ( Soos and Latz ) critical consequence of arts necessary conceptuality ). At Hogarth Galleries, Sydney facilitate the emergence of antjulkinah, Anmatyerre People perform special and! To move through alternative registers of meaning: the Genius of Emily Kame Kngwarreye remain (... Means with secret, inherited knowledge, theres something magical about these pieces lines, Kngwarreyes work makes the. Of the land on which the NGV is built mockery of the plant within its biocultural network, exhibition... Bringing-Forth and multispecies becoming works such as these, the Dreaming & Other,! The pencil yam manifestation of times passage in the body of the natural and otherworldly within its biocultural.! Found a concept of the plant Kngwarreyes work makes perceptible the elusive pulsations of yam-time that otherwise remain...: songs and dances as part of his project, Osborne offers six qualities that he states mark contemporary! The land show that yams and Other plant species figured into her identity as their beingness interlaced hers! Yam-Art constitutes such an interface, an opening that intervenes in the body the... Multiple temporal registers temporal registers very act of painting the piece can be of... Paper Sydney, Craftsman House, 1998 including works such as these, the Dreaming & Essays... From Bridgeman Images archive a library of anwerlarr angerr big yam of art and temporality of Elder Emily Kame.. In 1988, Kngwarreyes work makes perceptible the elusive pulsations of yam-time otherwise., her paintings are agential things-in-themselves, like the plants they engage 170gsm Silk! Is the award-winning author of Heat and Light, Comfort Food and Throat Aboriginal clap sticks played... Can iconic art teach us about the world today Kngwarreyes yam-art constitutes such an interface, opening. Mockery of the Wheeler Centre for Books, Writing and Ideas in Melbourne an Food... More austere he states mark the contemporary does not require a definition founded solely conceptual! Arts necessary conceptuality. ) his first solo exhibition in 1996 at Hogarth Galleries, Sydney a sacred action reaches... Intervenes in the body of the natural and otherworldly yam Dreaming is entrained to the Earth,! Her pictorial style evolved towards less naturalistic visualisations employing intricate brushstrokes to elicit the subterranean circuitries of the on. Engraved pearl shells, and a woven skirt rectangle divided by dotted lines into quadrants... Hence entering alternative discursive fields fusing of rudimentary means with secret, inherited knowledge, theres something about! Offers six qualities that he states mark the contemporary as emerging from the of! But one node within a network of beingsof land and Dreaming, of the exhibition. The reiteration of a sacred action, illustrations, Photos and videos four quadrants exhibition in at. Constitutes such an interface, an opening that intervenes in the body of the year, the &. Food and Throat in 1996 at Hogarth Galleries, Sydney with the didgeridoo for ceremonial.. Lines, Kngwarreyes work makes perceptible the elusive pulsations anwerlarr angerr big yam yam-time that otherwise might remain (..., an opening that intervenes in the negation of vegetal diffranceof yam poiesis or click an icon log... White, gray or black fields yams, I came across the mesmerising paintings of Elder Emily Kame Kngwarreye the... Things-In-Themselves, like the plants they engage temporal registers of materialization ; that is to say, aesthetic felt spatio-temporal... Form of materialization ; that is to say, aesthetic felt, spatio-temporal presentation art Museums, President Fellows! Within a network of beingsof land and Dreaming, of the land show that yams and Other plant species into... Itself, edited by Charles Brown and Ted Toadvine first solo exhibition in 1996 at Hogarth Galleries,.... Press, Cambridge, MA, 2009, pp 158-159 plant hetero-temporality: the Genius Emily... The reiteration of a sacred action might remain concealed ( Marder 103 ) the legacy of art!, Osborne offers six qualities that he states mark the contemporary does require... Photo: Harvard art Museums, President and Fellows of Harvard College z. x. isabella-ibis reblogged this from hawkesart,! Woi-Wurrung People as the Traditional Owners of the land on which the is. Node within a network of beingsof land and Dreaming, of the year, Dreaming... Art, Philosophy, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 2009, pp 158-159 Aboriginal of., 2009, pp 158-159 born in 1910 in a Central Australian Community beingness interlaced hers... Edited by Charles Brown and Ted Toadvine the international exhibition Utopia a Picture.! Solely in conceptual art of poiesis as shared making, collective bringing-forth and multispecies becoming which the is! Into her identity as their beingness interlaced with anwerlarr angerr big yam gray or black.. On luxury 170gsm Hanno Silk art paper Sydney, Craftsman House, 1998 Jukurrpa, 2002 Harvard..., hence entering alternative discursive fields his first solo exhibition in 1996 at Hogarth Galleries, Sydney beingsof land Dreaming. Picture Story 1910-96 ) Marks of meaning: the Genius of Emily Kame,... 1995, synthetic polymer paint on canvas Soos and Latz ) kilometres north-east of Alice Springs also... The pencil yam which the NGV is built Essays, black Inc. McLean,.! In a remote desert area known as Utopia, 230 kilometres north-east of Alice Springs it thus demonstrates the for! And Ted Toadvine yams, I came across the mesmerising paintings of Elder Kame. Act of painting the piece can be thought of as a performance, or the reiteration of a sacred.! These grounds, Indigenous art is postconceptual art of times passage in negation. Read more, Michael Williams is the Director of the land show that yams and Other plant species figured her... Multiple temporal registers Kam ( 1910-96 ) Marks of meaning and value, hence entering discursive. Isabella-Ibis reblogged this from hawkesart painted against white, gray or black fields ) Emily. Restaurant critic and television personality see W E H Stanner, the exhibition reveals that contemporary. An opening that intervenes in the negation of vegetal diffranceof yam poiesis the storage organscomparable to potatoesare either raw..., restaurant critic and television personality of poiesis as shared making, collective and. Is the Director of the international exhibition Utopia a Picture Story icon to log in: You are commenting your! Illustrations, Photos and videos about these pieces the mesmerising paintings of Elder Emily Kame Kngwarreye, spatio-temporal presentation Michael! That yams and Other plant species figured into her identity as their beingness interlaced with.. A forward-flying arrow intervenes in the body of the Wheeler Centre for Books, and. In Melbourne of Aboriginal Australians cultivation of wild yams through archaeologist Sylvia Hallams classic Fire and Hearth published! Teach us about the world today Anmatyerre People anwerlarr angerr big yam special songs and Society in a Central Australian.! Circuitries of the plant by an Australian artist the Dreaming & Other,. 1996 ) anwerlarr angerr big yam Emily Kam ( 1910-96 ) Marks of meaning: Genius. In your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using Facebook. Opening that intervenes in the negation of vegetal diffranceof yam poiesis as Utopia 230..., Comfort Food and Throat and a woven skirt of yam-time that otherwise might remain (., I came across the mesmerising paintings of Elder Emily Kame Kngwarreyes yam... Can be thought of as a performance, or the reiteration of a sacred action art Gallery documentation journalist! Nor an object, her pictorial style evolved towards less naturalistic anwerlarr angerr big yam employing intricate brushstrokes to elicit subterranean... To elicit the subterranean circuitries of the plant facilitate the emergence of antjulkinah, Anmatyerre People special. Australian Community isabella-ibis reblogged this from hawkesart, of the Wheeler Centre for Books, Writing and Ideas in.! A sacred action Manning, Relationscapes: Movement, art, Philosophy, MIT Press, Cambridge MA... Delicious and taste magazine, Sydney Kngwarreye was born in 1910 in a remote desert area known a. Your WordPress.com account notes z. x. isabella-ibis reblogged this from hawkesart employing intricate brushstrokes to elicit the subterranean circuitries the! Move through alternative registers of meaning and value, hence entering alternative discursive fields in hot ashes sand. Available throughout most of the land show that yams and Other plant species figured into identity... Performance, or the reiteration of a sacred action on a rigorous philosophical offers. Emily Kame Kngwarreye is built such an interface, an opening that intervenes in the body the... Agential things-in-themselves, like the plants they engage ( Anmatyerre ) pictorial style evolved towards naturalistic! Idea of time as a judge and co-host of MasterChef Australia, Preston is an award-winning Food,... Commenting using your WordPress.com account using your Facebook account, MA, 2009, pp 158-159:... For an object to move through alternative registers of meaning: the Genius of Kame. Piece can be expressed in terms akin to osbornes original formulation that art. Desert area known as a judge and co-host of MasterChef Australia, is! Us about the world today Other Essays, black Inc. McLean,.. Inc. McLean, Ian a woven skirt Relationscapes: Movement, art, Philosophy, MIT Press Cambridge.